Teenagers have sex. There. I said it.

2008 June 5
by Jamelle

At Tapped, Dana Goldstein reports on yet another pro-abstinence only education group, “Parents for Truth”:

The U.S. has spent $1.5 billion on abstinence-only sex education programs. Seventeen states, responding to research concluding abstinence-only doesn’t work, have rejected the federal dollars associated with these programs so they can pursue reality-based comprehensive sex-ed. After all, over 9 out of 10 Americans have premarital sex — and that number has been fairly constant throughout the twentieth century, even before the sexual revolution of the 1960s.

That’s the evidence-backed, medically and sociologically sound truth. But abstinence hawks aren’t accepting it. Instead, they are launchingParents for Truth,” a $1 million national campaign aimed at pressuring school districts and states to accept the Bush administration’s federal funds for abstinence-only. A video created by the National Abstinence Education Associate, which is leading the campaign, is completely deceiving. It shows a mom walking into a huge suburban kitchen after work, where her young teen daughter is doing homework at the table. Mom gets a phone call from another mother, who’s enraged over a sex-ed program called “Be Proud! Be Responsible!” A page of the program’s text book is shown on which “taking a shower together” is called a “green light” sexual behavior.

From the Parents for Truth FAQ:

Abstinence education realizes that “having sex” can potentially affect a lot more than the sex organs of teens, but as research shows, can also have emotional, psychological, social, economic and educational consequences. That’s why topics frequently discussed in an abstinence education class include:

  • How to identify a healthy relationship
  • How to avoid or get out of a dangerous, unhealthy, or abusive relationship
  • Developing skills to make good decisions
  • Setting goals for the future and taking realistic steps to reach them
  • Understanding and avoiding STDs
  • Information about contraceptives and their effectiveness against pregnancy and STDs
  • Practical ways to avoid inappropriate sexual advances
  • Why abstinence until marriage is optimal

So, within an abstinence education program, teens receive all the information they need in order to make healthy choices. That’s a lot of information and skills packed into an abstinence curriculum! And all of these topics are taught within the context of why abstinence is the best choice. There’s nothing “only” about the abstinence approach!

Notice anything missing?  You know, like talking about contraception.  The main page on the Parents for Truth website touts the shocking statistic that 1 in 4 teenage girls have a sexually transmitted disease,  but it definitely seems like the organization isn’t actually interested in preventing teen pregnancy or the spread of STDs.  The facts are pretty much clear at this point: abstinence-only education programs simply (even “inclusive” ones) don’t work.  There is a marked increase in STDs and teen pregnancy in areas where school districts have embraced abstinence-only programs.

I completely support promoting abstinence to teenagers.  I’ve spent the last two summers as a camp counselor for fifteen-year olds, and trust me, the last thing any of them should be doing is having sex.  Promoting abstinence however, doesn’t mean that you endorse ignorance.  Parents and educators need to accept the fact that at least a solid plurality of teenagers will be sexually active by the time they graduate.  And instead of abandoning them and thus putting them at risk for disease or pregnancy, we should equip them with the tools and information necessary to live a healthy life.  Which means, “Parents for Truth,” educating teenagers about safe sex and contraception.

5 Responses leave one →
  1. 2008 June 7

    I’m with you on this.

    I’m all for promoting abstinence, and I like everything about the abstinence agenda (except maybe those KMart pants you referenced the other day) except pretending that contraception doesn’t exist.

    I halfway buy the argument that it sends mixed messages, but so does the whole culture. However …

    Some people use contraceptives even if they wait until they’re married. Teaching people what the options are isn’t necessarily a bad thing.

  2. 2008 June 8
    Sam Hill permalink

    There is an error with this post.

    From the Parents for Truth FAQ included in your article:
    “That’s why topics frequently discussed in an abstinence education class include:
    … (Sixth bullet point) Information about contraceptives and their effectiveness against pregnancy and STDs”

    Your Following Paragraph:
    “Notice anything missing? You know, like talking about contraception.”

    I don’t think its necessary for me to connect the dots.

    Your article is thoughtful, but unless I am missing something with the above error, seems to be applying itself to a mold without realizing.

  3. 2008 June 8

    Hmm. Oops.

  4. 2008 June 8
    Ben permalink

    Dear Sir,

    I took the trouble to click on the links you provided and I was wondering why you called the video on the ParentsforTruth website “deceiving.” The Be Proud! Be Responsible! is a real curriculum that is used nationally as “comprehensive sex education.” Googling the program further reveals that it indeed has the information that the video claims it does.

    Also, since as Sam Hill pointed out, abstinence education does indeed include information about contraceptives and their effectiveness, I wonder what is your qualm with abstinence programs?

  5. 2008 June 9
    Thomas permalink

    Actually, I thought the videos on that website were pretty misleading and kinda obnoxious.

    In the one video the woman actually says that they are encouraging sexual activity at schools.

    Um….no? I certainly don’t remember that at my school. I do remember making an “abstinence pledge” though. I signed my name and everything. Which seemed pretty ridiculous.

    It’s true though. Kids are going to have sex and they really need to step up educating them about the horrors of what will happen if they don’t use contraceptives. I mean, I wasn’t having sex back then but that’s probably because at that point there just wasn’t an opportunity– I was a complete loser. But seriously, if teenagers are in an environment where they can have sex, it’s gonna happen and we should just be instructing them based on this assumption.

    I do think that even if you do mention contraceptives but the larger part of your message is abstinence that most young people just tune you right out. They’ve already decided to go against half of what you’re advocating so why would they relate to you and listen to the rest of it. It just doesn’t seem like a good angle to approach teenagers from.

    Anyway, what’s the big deal? Just TELL YOUR KIDS WHATEVER YOU WANT THEM TO KNOW WHEN THEY GET HOME. Same as with prayer in schools and that crap. Boo hoo my kids aren’t forced to pray in schools. Well…FORCE THEM WHEN THEY GET HOME. Honestly, it’s called parenting. Did you forget that they’re yours to indoctrinate as you see fit? WHy aren’t you taking advantage of that? Or are you just lazy? Seriously? You’re so lazy that the school have to instruct them and make them “moral” too? What are you so busy doing?

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS