The Return of Pro-Life Terrorism

2009 May 31

George Tiller, a doctor who provided late-term therapeutic abortions to women facing severe pregnancy-related complications, was shot to death as he entered his church this morning.  Considering the amount of vitriol and violence directed towards Tiller over the past twenty years – he was shot in 1993, and since then, has been vilified by the national “pro-life” movement as the “doctor of death” – it’s a pretty safe bet that Tiller was murdered by a pro-life “Christian” extremist.  By any definition of the word, this is a tragedy; Tiller dedicated his life, in the face of constant threats and violence, to providing a necessary and life-saving medical service to thousands of women.  Amanda Marcotte writes at Pandagon:

He didn’t have to do this.  He didn’t have to put his life and his family’s life on the line every day to tend to women going through a little-understood trauma.  He didn’t have to go through a sea of protesters who hate women so much they actually think that women are lying about their problems so they “get” to have later term abortions.  He didn’t have to suffer through relentless legal abuse at the hands of fundamentalist misogynists who obtain political power by exploiting voter ignorance about abortion.  He didn’t have to make himself the target for this murder to help women, but for whatever reason, he rose to this challenge, and that makes him a real hero.

I think it’s clear that Tiller’s murder flowed directly out of the “by any means necessary” rhetoric of the pro-life movement.  Pro-choicers are regularly derided as “baby-killers” and “murderers,” and abortion providers are routinely subject to protests and threats.  And while the mainstream pro-life movement isn’t directly responsible for Dr. Tiller’s death, it must account for its considerable role in contributing to a climate where someone is driven to violence – to kill a man in front of his wife – over a political disagreement.

4 Responses leave one →
  1. 2009 May 31

    I notice you don’t provide a link to your smear of “the ‘by any means necessary’ rhetoric of the pro-life movement.” I’d like to be able to help you out here, but since the only such rhetoric I’ve ever heard comes from the far Left, trying to smear Pro-Lifers (and equally unsupported), I’m afraid I can’t help you.

    By the way, we don’t even know, yet, what the motivation for this murder was, and it’s nothing more than political ambulance chasing to assume the motive without knowing.

  2. 2009 June 1
    Thomas permalink

    The quote you referenced has a very good point in it. There is a lot of vilification of the specific people who conduct abortions (and not just the law allowing it). But I don’t get it: do these people really think that the doctors enjoy this work and think of it as anything other than a horrible necessity?

    Also, James Young makes me laugh.

  3. 2009 June 3

    I returned to the States 11 months ago after being in Europe for 20 years. What struck me as insane and unjust 21 years ago rings even truer today! Pro-lifers will go to any lengths to get their point across: murder being the main line of attack and twisted reasoning. That flies contradictory hypocritical horseshit right in their own rhetorical faces. Yet what is the punishment? Is there any retribution? The death of this brave and committed doctor is unpardonable. Those responsible are dangerously ignorant and excused. They ought to be incarcerated. Is that being done? Are they standing trial? In such cases, I firmly believe there ought to be direct imprisonment with public service work. At an abortion clinic!

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. The Typical Pro-Life response to Dr. George Tiller’s Death « Smash Mouth Politics

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS